Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis faces a decision on the future of the transfer of development rights on Monday, caught between the political cost of a confrontation with mayors from Athens’s northern suburbs and the risk of triggering a domino effect of changes to the country’s urban planning framework.
The crucial meeting at the Maximos Mansion comes amid strong opposition to the proposed Transfer of Development Rights Zones (ZYS), with the possibility of suspending the process entirely still on the table. However, there are also compelling arguments for allowing it to continue, provided the studies are substantially corrected and revised wherever necessary.
Despite the considerable political stakes, people with detailed knowledge of the plans believe the government will seek a way to defuse the opposition without scrapping the reform altogether. The preferred solution would be to revise the studies where necessary and reconsider the proposed receiving areas, given that the plans currently under public consultation do not constitute final urban planning decisions.
Nothing, however, has been decided in advance. A reliable source at the Ministry of Environment and Energy said the prime minister would make the final decision himself, after hearing both the mayors’ objections and the arguments of Environment and Energy Minister Stavros Papastavrou and Secretary-General for Spatial Planning Evangelos Kyriazopoulos, who are expected to set out the methodology behind the studies and the rationale for the planning framework.
Several options remain under consideration, ranging from extending the public consultation period beyond the current two months and making substantial amendments to bringing the process to a halt. A blanket suspension, however, is viewed with reservations by those defending the reform’s underlying principles, because of the wider planning and economic consequences it could have.
‘This is not the final text’
The statements made in recent hours by Deputy Prime Minister Kostis Hatzidakis and Environment and Energy Minister Stavros Papastavrou, both attending the meeting, as well as Health Minister Adonis Georgiadis, one of the MPs representing areas where much of the opposition has been voiced, offer an indication of the government’s approach.
The Deputy Prime Minister described the matter as a “technical and legal” discussion, calling on all sides to “take a responsible position and find a consensual solution”.
Speaking to Skai radio, Hatzidakis clarified: “First, the text that has been put out for consultation, as the word itself suggests, is not final. And second, the government has made it clear that the transfer of development rights from one municipality to another is ruled out.”
“The transfer of development rights is an urban planning tool. The mayors are right to raise their concerns, in the sense that they have a duty to protect the interests of their citizens. We want fewer plots of land to be built on,” the Environment and Energy Minister explained.
Asked about the reasons for the backlash, Papastavrou replied: “It may be that the way the data on playgrounds or public spaces has been recorded in the studies needs to be improved.”
“We are at a very early stage, but there is a perception that anything put out for public consultation is already final. There is no draft bill and no presidential decree. The study must be corrected and made accurate; that is why it has been put out for public consultation. The study as an institution cannot be wrong, but if it shows a square in the wrong location, that must be corrected.”
In this context, he assured the public that “all observations and comments from the mayors will be taken into account”.
“For this to go ahead is out of the question. We are not going to legislate anything against the wishes of local communities. If there is an issue that needs to be resolved, that can be examined, clarified and explained, and we can discuss it and see whether some kind of solution can be found. The proposal, as it was presented and published, did not come out in the right way,” Health Minister Adonis Georgiadis said.
“This is not legislation; it is a public consultation,” Georgiadis added. “Residents of all these areas should not be worried. They have MPs and ministers representing them, and we will not leave them without representation or protection. More discussion and better information should have been provided.”
Six mayors head to Maximos Mansion seeking withdrawal of the plans
Representing local government, six mayors are due to arrive at the Maximos Mansion on Monday afternoon: Vassilis Xypolytas, Mayor of Kifissia; Charalambos Bonatsos, Mayor of Filothei-Psychiko; Symeon Roussos, Mayor of Chalandri; Panagiotis Manouris, Mayor of Nea Ionia; Ilias Apostolopoulos, Mayor of Papagou-Cholargos; and Marios Psychalis, Mayor of Lykovrysi-Pefki. They have formed a united front against the proposed planning framework.
The six mayors have already formally expressed their opposition, calling in a joint letter to the prime minister for the withdrawal of the Strategic Environmental Impact Assessment currently under consultation and a complete reassessment of the plans from the beginning, with meaningful participation from local government.
Their common position was reaffirmed at a recent meeting at the Regional Union of Municipalities of Attica, chaired by its president and Mayor of Galatsi, George Markopoulos.
The municipalities’ objections are not limited to the prospect of additional building space. They concern the selection of the proposed receiving areas, the capacity of existing infrastructure and the potential impact on population density and the residential character of Athens’s northern suburbs.
The joint demand for withdrawal gives Monday’s meeting particular political significance, as the government is being asked to respond to coordinated opposition from six municipal authorities rather than isolated local objections.
The studies are not a final plan: the zero-option scenario
One of the main arguments the ministry is expected to put forward is that the studies currently under public consultation do not amount to final urban planning decisions.
The process has been in preparation for around two years, drawing on information from existing town plans, municipal operational plans and recorded requirements for public spaces and facilities serving the community.
The purpose of the consultation is to examine the assumptions made by the researchers, assess comments from municipal technical departments and incorporate substantiated objections from local authorities. Against this background, revising studies in areas where serious planning problems have been identified is emerging as a possible way to ease the confrontation.
Particular attention has been drawn to the fact that the studies also provide for a zero-option scenario which, according to the Ministry of Environment and Energy, can be selected by the municipality and the regional authority as part of the process.
The ministry nevertheless argues that municipalities must also bear the cost of their choices if they reject the creation of Transfer of Development Rights Zones, rather than taking state funding for the preservation of public spaces and community facilities for granted.
“Municipalities cannot reject Transfer of Development Rights Zones and at the same time demand that the state pay compensation to prevent the loss of a square or a school,” ministry sources said.
They also raised the following question: “When expropriations begin to be lifted in Kifissia and new buildings are constructed next to listed buildings, will that not alter the character of the town?”
The 584,000 square metres at the centre of the dispute
At the heart of the confrontation between the state and local authorities are up to 584,000 square metres of potential additional building capacity that the proposed zones in the northern suburbs are expected to accommodate, prompting concerns that the area’s residential character could be altered.
Officials at the Ministry of Environment and Energy defending the plans insist that no new building rights are being created.
“These are not imaginary square metres we have made up. These square metres already exist.”
According to the officials, the proposal does not involve new development rights, but existing rights provided for in the town plans and urban planning studies for Kifissia and Psychiko.
“However, for the urban planning framework to be implemented, these rights must be compensated. Otherwise, the provisions of the town plans will remain impossible to put into practice,” the same source said.
However, the fact that these rights already exist does not alter the fact that transferring them increases the permitted building capacity of the receiving properties. This is where the municipalities’ main objection lies: they question whether their areas can accommodate additional building space without putting further pressure on infrastructure or changing their residential character.
One example illustrates how the mechanism works. If the building coefficient in an area rises from 0.6 to 0.7, a plot measuring 1,000 square metres would be entitled to a total of 700 square metres of building space, rather than 600. The additional 100 square metres create a financial incentive to purchase transferred development rights, allowing the owner of another property designated for use as a square to receive compensation.
The central question, therefore, is how much additional development the receiving areas can accommodate and what urban planning criteria have been used to determine their capacity.
The €2bn bill and the future of public spaces
Behind the dispute lies the long-standing inability of municipalities to compensate property owners whose land has been reserved for squares, schools, green spaces and road-widening projects.
Sources defending the plans estimate that potential compensation requirements could reach as much as €2bn, reflecting the high cost of land in these areas.
The lack of funding has left urban planning provisions dating back decades unimplemented. The Ministry of Environment and Energy warns that, unless the necessary compensation is secured, spaces designated for public use and community facilities could be lost.
Examples cited include cases in Psychiko, Kifissia and Chalandri, where, according to the same argument, squares, school and sports facilities, or planned road-widening projects have been lost for similar reasons.
Listed-property owners are also a significant part of the equation, and their concerns are particularly acute. They hold unused development rights but face substantial maintenance costs.
The ministry argues that funding from the Green Fund and the “I Preserve” programmes is insufficient to meet these needs. It presents the transfer of development rights as an alternative compensation mechanism, allowing owners to realise the value of their unused building capacity rather than relying exclusively on public funding.
“Imagine people who have effectively been deprived of the ability to make use of their property so that the architectural character of an area can be preserved. Owners with unused building coefficients of as much as 2.1, who have been left bearing a financial burden by the state and now risk losing the opportunity to make use of their development rights as well,” ministry sources said.
Fears of a domino effect on urban planning
Beyond the financial cost, a blanket suspension of the Transfer of Development Rights Zones is considered capable of setting a precedent with wider implications for urban planning reform.
The concern within the Ministry of Environment and Energy is that if the government decides to halt the consultation process in response to local opposition, it will be extremely difficult to resist similar demands when Local and Special Urban Plans begin to be published.
Any municipality that disagrees with the provisions of a plan could then seek similar political intervention to stop the process.
The argument carries weight. However, given that the planning process has already fallen behind schedule, it is difficult to see it progressing before the elections.
Sources also say that, immediately after meeting the mayors on Monday, the Environment and Energy Minister is due to discuss the urban planning schemes with Kyriakos Mitsotakis, so that final decisions can be taken on the direction of the major reform.
“The issue takes on an even greater dimension because urban planning is part of the commitments the country has undertaken towards the European Union, backed by funding of around €400m from the Recovery and Resilience Facility. This includes the studies for the Transfer of Development Rights Zones,” a ministry official stressed.
Greece has committed to completing the relevant studies and putting them out for consultation so that the urban planning process can move forward. This does not mean that a possible suspension of the zones would automatically lead to the loss of European funding, but it highlights the difficulty of halting a process that forms part of a wider reform programme.
The progress of the Transfer of Development Rights Zones is also linked to the future operation of the Digital Land Bank, a key tool for activating the transfer of development rights mechanism.
The wider debate over the future of urban planning also encompasses outstanding issues concerning building outside designated urban zones and the recognition of public roads, a crucial requirement for determining whether properties outside urban plans can be developed, in accordance with the case law of the Council of State.
Political cost and the difficult balancing act facing Maximos Mansion
Despite the planning and economic arguments, the political dimension remains decisive.
Opposition from municipalities in the northern suburbs has already placed the government under considerable pressure, while the involvement of government officials in local discussions shows that reservations about the plans are not confined to local authorities.
Even among those who defend the principles behind the Transfer of Development Rights Zones, there is recognition that the ministry has not handled the issue successfully in terms of public communication.
“Political cost matters, but people need to understand the consequences of failing to plan and simply leaving things as they are,” said a person familiar with the issue, acknowledging that mistakes had been made in communicating the plans and that neither the mechanism nor the problems it seeks to address had been explained in good time.
“The municipalities’ ‘no’ does not tell us anything. The solution is to say: come and look at the study, and these are our views,” ministry sources countered.
They acknowledged that the studies currently under public consultation are not an immutable plan, leaving room for substantial revisions and amendments based on substantiated objections and proposals from local authorities.
The question is whether the scope for changes will prove sufficient to bridge the differences, or whether Monday’s meeting will further expose the gap between the government’s determination to save the reform and the municipalities’ demand that the plans be withdrawn.
Ask me anything
Explore related questions
