×
GreekEnglish

×
  • Politics
  • Diaspora
  • World
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Culture
  • Sports
  • Cooking
Thursday
19
Nov 2026
weather symbol
Athens 21°C
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • World
  • Diaspora
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Culture
  • Sports
  • Mediterranean Cooking
  • Weather
Contact follow Protothema:
Powered by
> World

Juror who blocked Lindsay Clancy insanity acquittal over children’s murders speaks out for first time: “I believed there was enough evidence that she had planned it”

Michael P. Desronvil, rather than being praised for his courage, has faced organised online attacks and threats from the feminist movement

Newsroom September 18 10:19

Δείτε περισσότερα άρθρα μας στα αποτελέσματα αναζήτησης

Add Protothema.gr on Google

The juror who refused to find Lindsay Clancy not guilty by reason of insanity in Massachusetts, leading to a mistrial, has spoken publicly for the first time, defending his position against those who accused him of refusing to change his mind despite the doubts he had expressed.

During the trial and afterwards, Clancy received a wave of support from feminists across the US, which shocked the public.

Michael P. Desronvil, 48, was the only one of the 12 jurors who courageously refused to agree that Clancy should be found not guilty by reason of insanity for the murder of her three young children. His disagreement led to the jury deadlocking after a six-week trial and placed him at the center of an intense public dispute.

In a statement to NewsNation, Desronvil rejected claims that he had doubts about Clancy’s guilt and then simply refused to back down. ‘I did not have doubts. When I was trying to explain different possible theories during the jury deliberations, I was interrupted as though that meant I had doubts based on the evidence that was available,’ he said. ‘Based on all the evidence, the key witnesses and what the prosecution presented, I believed there was enough evidence that she knew exactly what she was doing and had planned it,’ he added.

It should be recalled that, under US law, a defendant can be convicted or acquitted only if the jurors unanimously believe that their guilt or innocence, respectively, has been established ‘beyond a reasonable doubt’.

The case that shook Massachusetts

Lindsay Clancy, 36, had admitted to killing her three children at her home in Duxbury in 2023 and then attempting to take her own life.

Her defence argued that, at the time of her actions, she was suffering from severe post-partum depression and a mental breakdown, which had been exacerbated by the medication she was taking in an effort to treat her condition. The prosecution, however, argued that Clancy was aware of her actions and that they were the result of planning.

Desronvil was the only juror who rejected the defence’s argument of mental incapacity, meaning that there was no unanimous verdict and a mistrial was declared.

Religion and the juror’s past come under scrutiny

In an effort to discredit Desronvil, the feminist movement has embarked on a ‘safari’ to find anything that could tarnish his integrity. Some argued that he had been influenced by his deeply held Catholic faith, as the prosecution referred during the trial to the concept of ‘mortal sin’ in relation to the killings and suicide. His own brother, however, rejected that interpretation, saying that he did not believe religion had anything to do with his decision.

>Related articles

Putin on trilateral meeting with Trump and Xi: ‘No one divided up the world at Yalta’

The “New Yalta” lasted 80 minutes: The winners and losers of the historic Xi, Trump and Putin meeting

Record sales for the 72-hour Emergency Kit

Desronvil comes from a family of Haitian immigrants who settled in Massachusetts in 1982. He was about four years old when he arrived in the United States. People from his family and social circle described him as a member of an educated and respectable family, while until recently he worked in pest control.

The disclosure of his identity triggered a fresh wave of reactions, followed by reports about previous allegations against him. According to US media reports, he was arrested in 2021 following a complaint over an alleged domestic violence incident, during which he was said to have assaulted his then wife. The charges were ultimately dropped because the woman did not testify, according to reports, due to fears related to child custody. In 2025, he was also accused of assaulting his nephew, leading to a restraining order being issued against him. These reports raised questions about the process for selecting jurors in a trial involving a domestic violence case.

The tension surrounding Desronvil led the judge in the case, William Sullivan, to block the release of the jurors’ names in an effort to limit their exposure. However, according to US media, Desronvil had already left the area with his new wife. An auto repair shop owner who said he knew the family said that his wife had recently visited the shop and requested work on her car. ‘She said there was media madness going on and that they would keep a low profile for a while,’ he said.

Ask me anything

Explore related questions

#court#feminists#juror#Lindsay Clancy#Michael P. Desronvil#mistrial#usa#world
> More World

Follow en.protothema.gr on Google News and be the first to know all the news

See all the latest News from Greece and the World, the moment they happen, at en.protothema.gr

> Latest Stories

Trump tells Berlin summit from Air Force One that ‘Putin wants peace’ and criticises €70bn in new aid for Kyiv

November 19, 2026

Politico: Major cyberattack on European Commission, hackers may have accessed personal data

November 19, 2026

Mitsotakis joins Berlin summit as allies seek European role in Ukraine peace talks

November 19, 2026

Marinakis: We protect vulnerable and responsible borrowers, doing what previous governments failed to do

November 19, 2026

Putin urges Kyiv to accept US compromises and vows border buffer zones after talks with Trump and Xi

November 19, 2026

Michelin-Star restaurant Botrini’s raises the bar in the alcohol-free movement with a trailblazing pairing menu

November 19, 2026

Van Gogh painting sells for record $190.4 million after dispute nearly derailed auction

November 19, 2026

Man tried to resuscitate his wife after strangling her in Thiseio

November 19, 2026
All News

> Greece

In reverence, the emotional deposition in Jerusalem, see photos & video

The Holy Temple of the Resurrection opened after many days due to the war between Israel and Iran

April 10, 2026

In the final stretch for the accreditation of joint master’s degrees: Aiming for their launch in the coming academic year

April 10, 2026

Schedule for Epitaph Procession today (10/4)

April 10, 2026

Perfect weather for Easter excursions, according to Tsatrafyllia’s forecast

April 10, 2026

Easter in Greece: The customs that continue in Greek tradition – From Nafpaktos to Corfu

April 10, 2026
Homepage
PERSONAL DATA PROTECTION POLICY COOKIES POLICY TERM OF USE
Powered by Cloudevo
Copyright © 2026 Πρώτο Θέμα