Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis must decide today between the political cost of a confrontation with the mayors of the northern suburbs and the risk of triggering a domino effect of upheavals in the country’s urban planning system, as he considers the future of the transfer of building coefficients.
The crucial meeting at the Maximos Mansion is taking place against the backdrop of strong reactions to the Designated Receiving Zones for Building Coefficients (ZYS), with the possibility of a complete suspension still on the table. At the same time, there are strong arguments in favor of continuing the process, through substantial corrections and revisions to the studies wherever deemed necessary.
Despite the considerable political weight of the dispute, the assessment expressed by people with an excellent understanding of the planning process is that the government will seek a way out that can defuse the opposition without scrapping the reform as a whole. In this direction, the ideal solution would be to revise the studies where appropriate and reconsider the designated receiving areas, given that the planning proposal currently under public consultation does not constitute a final urban planning decision.
However, nothing is considered to have been decided in advance. A reliable source at the Ministry of Environment and Energy points out that the prime minister will make the final decisions himself, after hearing both the mayors’ objections and the arguments of Environment and Energy Minister Stavros Papastavrou and Secretary-General for Spatial Planning Evangelos Kyriazopoulos, who will present the methodology behind the studies and the underlying philosophy of the planning framework.
Various scenarios remain under consideration, ranging from continuing the consultation process with a longer period than the current two months and making substantial amendments, to terminating the process altogether. A complete freeze, however, is being viewed with reservations by those defending the philosophy of the reform, because of the wider urban planning and economic consequences it could trigger.
This is not the final text
The statements made in recent hours by Kostis Hatzidakis and Stavros Papastavrou, both of whom are participating in the meeting, as well as by Adonis Georgiadis, a member of parliament representing one of the areas from which most of the complaints have emerged, were indicative of the government’s efforts to manage the issue.
The Deputy Prime Minister described the matter as a “technical and legal” discussion, calling on everyone “to state their positions responsibly and find a consensual solution.” Speaking to SKAI radio, Kostis Hatzidakis clarified: “First, the text that has been put out for consultation, as the word itself indicates, is not final. And second, the government has made it clear that the transfer of building coefficients from one municipality to another is ruled out.”
“The transfer of building coefficients is an urban planning tool. The mayors are right to raise their voices in the sense that they have an obligation to protect the interests of their citizens. We want fewer plots of land to be built on,” the Minister of Environment and Energy explained.
Asked about the reasons behind the backlash, Stavros Papastavrou replied: “It may be that, in the studies carried out, the recording of information about playgrounds or public spaces needs improvement.”
“We are at a very early stage, but because there is a perception based on experience that whatever is put out for public consultation is already final, let me clarify that there is no draft bill and no Presidential Decree. The study needs to be corrected and made accurate; that is why it is being put out for public consultation. The study as an institution cannot be wrong. If it shows a square in the wrong location, that must be corrected.”
In this context, he assured that “all the observations and comments made by the mayors will be taken into account.”
“This is absolutely not going to go through as it stands. We are not generally going to legislate anything against the wishes of local communities. If there is an issue that needs to be examined to determine how it can be resolved, that may be possible. It will be clarified, explained, and discussed, and if some kind of solution exists, we will look at it. The way it was presented and published was not the right way,” the Minister of Health said.
“This is not legislation; it is a public consultation,” Adonis Georgiadis also said, adding: “Residents in all these areas should not be worried. They have members of parliament and ministers representing them, and they will not leave them either unrepresented or undefended. More discussion and more information should have been provided.”
The six mayors head to Maximos Mansion demanding withdrawal
Representing local government, six mayors are due to arrive at the Maximos Mansion around midday today: Vassilis Xypolytas of Kifissia, Charalambos Bonatsos of Filothei-Psychiko, Symeon Roussos of Chalandri, Panagiotis Manouris of Nea Ionia, Ilias Apostolopoulos of Papagou-Holargos, and Marios Psychalis of Lykovrysi-Pefki. They have formed a united front against the proposed planning framework.
The six mayors have already formally expressed their opposition, submitting a joint letter to the prime minister requesting the withdrawal of the Strategic Environmental Impact Assessment currently under public consultation and a reconsideration of the planning framework from scratch, with meaningful participation by local government.
This common position was also reaffirmed during their recent meeting at the Regional Union of Municipalities of Attica, chaired by its president and the mayor of Galatsi, Giorgos Markopoulos.
The municipalities’ objections are not limited to the additional square meters of construction. They concern the overall selection of the receiving areas, the adequacy of infrastructure, and the impact on population density and the residential character of the northern suburbs.
The joint demand for withdrawal gives today’s meeting particular political significance, as the government must respond to a coordinated reaction by six municipal administrations rather than to isolated local objections.
The studies do not constitute a final plan: The zero-option scenario
One of the main arguments the ministry’s representatives are expected to put forward today is that the studies currently under public consultation do not constitute final urban planning decisions. The planning process has been in preparation for approximately two years, drawing on information from existing city plans, municipalities’ operational plans, and documented needs for public spaces and facilities serving the community.
The purpose of the consultation is to check the assumptions made by the consultants, assess observations from municipal technical services, and incorporate substantiated objections from local authorities. In this context, revising studies in areas where serious urban planning problems are identified is emerging as a possible way to de-escalate the conflict.
Of particular interest is the observation that the studies also provide for a zero-option scenario, which, according to the Ministry of Environment and Energy, can be selected by the municipality and the regional authority as part of the process.
The ministry nevertheless points out that municipalities must also bear the cost of their choices if they reject the creation of Designated Receiving Zones for Building Coefficients, without taking state funding for the preservation of public spaces and community facilities for granted.
“Municipalities cannot reject the ZYS while simultaneously demanding that the state pay compensation to prevent a square or a school from being lost,” ministry sources say.
They also raise the following question: “When expropriations in Kifissia begin to be lifted and new buildings are constructed next to listed buildings, won’t that alter the city’s character?”
The 584,000 square meters and the dispute over construction
At the heart of the confrontation between the state and local authorities are up to 584,000 square meters of potential additional building capacity that the proposed zones in the northern suburbs are expected to be able to accommodate, raising concerns about changes to their residential character.
The Ministry of Environment and Energy, which is defending the planning framework, insists that no new building rights are being created.
“These are not imaginary square meters that we have made up. These square meters already exist.”
According to competent sources, this is not new construction capacity, but rather existing development rights provided for in the city plans and urban planning studies for Kifissia and Psychiko.
“However, for the urban planning framework to be implemented, these rights must be compensated. Otherwise, the provisions of the city plans will remain impossible to implement,” the same source points out.
Nevertheless, the fact that these rights already exist does not change the fact that transferring them increases the permitted building capacity of the receiving properties. This is where the municipalities’ main objection lies: they question whether their areas can absorb additional square meters without placing further strain on infrastructure and changing their residential character.
An example of the logic behind the planning framework is that increasing the building coefficient in an area from 0.6 to 0.7 allows a 1,000-square-meter plot to acquire building rights for 700 square meters instead of 600. The additional 100 square meters create a financial incentive to purchase transferred building rights, thereby compensating the owner of another property that is designated for use as a public square.
The question, therefore, is how much additional construction the receiving areas can accommodate and which urban planning criteria have been used to determine that capacity.
The €2 billion bill and public spaces
Behind the dispute lies the long-standing inability of municipalities to compensate property owners whose land has been earmarked for squares, schools, green spaces, and road extensions.
Sources defending the planning framework estimate that potential compensation needs could reach as much as €2 billion, owing to the high land prices in these areas.
The lack of resources has left urban planning provisions dating back decades unimplemented. The Ministry of Environment and Energy warns that, unless the necessary compensation is secured, there is a risk of losing spaces designated for public use and community facilities.
Examples cited include cases in Psychiko, Kifissia, and Chalandri, where, according to the same argument, squares, school and sports facilities, or planned road widenings have been lost for these very reasons.
Listed-building owners are also part of this equation, and their concerns are even more pronounced. They hold unused building rights but face high maintenance costs.
The ministry argues that funding from the Green Fund and the “Diatiro” preservation programs is insufficient to meet the needs. The transfer of building coefficients is therefore being presented as an alternative compensation mechanism, allowing owners to monetize their development rights rather than relying exclusively on public funding.
“Imagine people who have essentially been deprived of the ability to make use of their property so that the architectural character of an area can be preserved. Owners with unused building coefficients of as much as 2.1, whom the state has placed under a financial burden and now risks depriving of the ability to use their building rights as well,” ministry sources point out.
The fear of a domino effect in urban planning
Beyond the financial cost, a complete freeze on the Designated Receiving Zones is estimated to risk setting a precedent with wider consequences for the country’s urban planning reform.
The concern expressed within the Ministry of Environment and Energy is that, if the government decides to halt the consultation process under pressure from local opposition, it will be extremely difficult to deal with similar reactions when the Local and Special Urban Plans begin to be made public. Any municipality that disagrees with the provisions of a plan could demand a similar political intervention to stop the process.
This is an argument that has some basis. However, given that the planning process has already fallen far behind every timetable, it is difficult for it to move forward before the elections.
Reports also indicate that today, immediately after the meeting with the mayors, the Minister of Environment and Energy will discuss the issue of urban plans with Kyriakos Mitsotakis, in order to make final decisions on the course of the major reform.
“The problem takes on even greater dimensions because urban planning is part of the commitments the country has undertaken toward the European Union, backed by approximately €400 million in funding from the Recovery Fund, which also includes the studies for the Designated Receiving Zones for Building Coefficients,” a ministry official stresses.
The country has committed to completing the relevant studies and putting them out for consultation so that urban planning can move forward. This does not mean that a possible suspension of the ZYS would automatically lead to the loss of European funds. However, it highlights the difficulty of halting a process that forms part of a broader reform program.
In the same context, the progress of the ZYS is linked to the future operation of the Digital Land Bank, which is a key tool for activating the mechanism for transferring building coefficients.
The wider debate over the future of urban planning also includes pending issues concerning construction outside designated town plans and the recognition of public roads, which, according to the case law of the Council of State, is a crucial prerequisite for properties outside urban plans to be considered buildable.
The political cost and Maximos Mansion’s difficult balancing act
Despite the urban planning and economic arguments, the political dimension of the issue remains decisive.
Opposition from municipalities in the northern suburbs has already placed considerable pressure on the government, while the participation of government officials in local discussions highlights that reservations about the planning framework are not confined exclusively to local authorities.
Even among those defending the philosophy of the ZYS, there is recognition that the ministry’s communication strategy on the issue has not been successful.
“The political cost matters, but people must understand the consequences of failing to plan and simply remaining as we are,” admits a person familiar with the issue, acknowledging that communication mistakes were made and that neither the operation of the mechanism nor the problems it is intended to address were explained in a timely manner.
“The municipalities’ rejection does not tell us anything. The solution is to say: come and look at the study, and these are our views,” ministry sources counter. They acknowledge that the studies currently under public consultation do not constitute an unchangeable plan, leaving room for substantial revisions and amendments based on substantiated objections and proposals from local authorities.
The question is whether this scope for corrections will prove sufficient to bridge the differences, or whether today’s meeting will further highlight the gap between the government’s objective of saving the reform and the municipalities’ demand that the planning framework be withdrawn.
Ask me anything
Explore related questions
